cardshopfinder banner

Baseball Card Exchange

4 stars - based on 5 reviews

8519 Westfield Blvd.

Store Hours:

Monday 10:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Tuesday 10:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Wednesday 10:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Thursday 10:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Friday 10:00 a.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Saturday 10:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Closed Sunday

email logo
facebook logo Baseball Card Exchange
twitter logo @ballcardxchange

Reviews for Baseball Card Exchange

5 reviews

0 comments waiting approval.

   How did they rate Baseball Card Exchange?
   Name: Kevin
   Review: Great shop with lots of supplies and singles. They have boxes of .10 singles to go through as well as lots of unopened packs and boxes. Definantly worth the time for card collector's to visit.

   How did they rate Baseball Card Exchange?
   Name: Kin
   Review: I'd been to the shop a few times and depending who was working, my reviews would be mixed. However, since Andy bought it, I love going in. He always makes you feel like you're the most important customer to him, even if you're going in just to buy a $5 monster box or a few packs of sleeves. He knows my name and always appears happy to be there. Love the dime boxes. Love the atmosphere. I see more collectors in there these days that ever before. He also puts a lot of work into Facebook, Twitter and email to let customers know what's coming or already in. He also knows about the local card shows and is happy to direct you to them. I've been to quite a few local card shops in my day and this one is undoubtedly the best. The hobby needs more shops like this and owners like Andy. PSA: This is not Andy writing this!

   How did they rate Baseball Card Exchange?
   Name: Ryan
   Review: Great Shop! Andy is the type of owner we need in this hobby! He's really competitive with his prices and his singles! Definitely go check him out!!!

   How did they rate Baseball Card Exchange?
   Name: Brian
   Review: I stopped in on Monday, June 16. There were three people in the store, one behind the counter and two older gentlemen. The guy working looked at me when I entered, but didn't do as much as greet me. I was interested in looking at vintage baseball,and hopefully have a discussion, but I felt like I was interrupting their day. If the owner was there, then shame on him, but if it was an employee, then I hope the owner straightens him out.

   How did they rate Baseball Card Exchange?
   Name: Chris
   Review: My son and I have been visiting the shop for two years. The guys are always very patient and helpful. They often give my son and I freebies and great deals.

Have you been to Baseball Card Exchange? Help other sports card collectors from around the U.S. and the world, by leaving a comment about this trading card shop.

How would you rate Baseball Card Exchange?


Click here to return to:
Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana
Shops in Indiana
Home page

Latest Sportscard Releases